Pacific Northwest Ski blog (and a few other places!)

Lots or reports from skiing around the Pacific Northwest, with some East Coast excursions thrown in for good measure

A Sangiovese tasting

We’ve assembled a fair few decent Washington sangioveses recently, so figured it was a good time to do a taste test. In the mix we had (from Washington’s iconic wine maker) a Leonetti 2003, a Three Rivers Pepper Bridge Vineyard 2003 and a Walla Walla Vintners 2003. To add some interest, I threw in a Brokenwood 2004 Rayner Vineyard from South Australia, a wine that has slipped down very nicely recently with dinner.

We brown-bagged the four bottles, randomly mixed them up and started sampling enthusiastically. Amazingly, consensus between the 4 or us (Jan, Kathy, John, me) was quickly reached. The ‘left hand bottle’ was quite superb. Much more complex than the others, prominent cedary oak, spice and black cherry dominating the palate. The lingering velvety finish called everyone back for more. And it tasted like the best was yet to come.

We were evenly split on the two right-hand bottles. One was obviously the Brokenwood, its warm climate heritage and high alcohol revealing its identity. It was a fine stuff though, not subtle, but excellent fruit/oak balance. The second (preferred by moi) was a beautiful, elegant wine. Much lighter than the other three, bright cherry fruit, gentle oak and an acid structure all in wonderful harmony.

The remaining bottle started promisingly, but on a second taste everyone was disappointed – it seemed to fall apart. The acid was overly aggressive, tooth-enamel-eatingly so. The fruit was pleasant, but the palate didn’t come together cleanly, with the flavors simply not well integrated. No one rushed back for more of this one.

We all bet on which wine was which before removing them from their covers. And we were all wrong (apart from the Brokenwood). The results were:

1) Walla Walla Vintners
Joint 2) Three Rivers and Brokenwood (2 votes each)
4) Leonetti

So, it just goes to show that reputation and price mean nothing in a blind tasting like this. I suspect we’ll be tasting some Leonetti’s in a blind cabernet tasting quite soon, to see how it scrubs up in some more esteemed Washington and Australian company.
Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: